Let’s Hear It for the Dysfunctional Family


A review essay of the 2013 films “American Hustle,” “August: Osage County” and “Blue Jasmine.”

By Kathy Winings

kathy-winings-2If it were not for animated films, I’m not sure our children would see anything in today’s popular media that would recommend the beauty and value of marriage and family. Too many films that received Oscar nods this year portrayed marriage and family as either a lost cause or totally dysfunctional. I’m referring to three where either the film or its lead actors were nominated for the 2014 Academy Awards: “American Hustle,” “August: Osage County” and “Blue Jasmine.”

The acting in each was Oscar-worthy. However, anyone watching those films would come to the conclusion that the American family is lost forever and there is little hope of anyone reclaiming the ideal God envisioned for marriage and family.

Set in the 1970s, “American Hustle” portrays a con artist, Irving (Christian Bale), and his girlfriend, Sydney (Amy Adams), who spend their days setting up Ponzi and get-rich-quick schemes. Unfortunately, they get caught in a sting operation led by an FBI agent (Bradley Cooper). To avoid charges, Irving suggests he can help the FBI set up a major undercover operation that will expose a mafia boss and local politician. An elaborate operation is set up to catch the newly-elected mayor of Camden and a major mafia boss in the act of defrauding the citizens of New Jersey. There are plots and sub-plots with so many twists that the viewer isn’t quite sure until the very end who is crooked, who isn’t, who will end up in prison, and who will walk away.

But the sub-theme running throughout the film is the relationship between Irving, Sydney and his wife Rosalyn (Jennifer Lawrence) and young son. Irving views himself as a good husband and father, despite that he’s a con artist and has a mistress.

What fuels his image of being a good man is he took pity on a homeless young single mother, gave her and her toddler a home, married her and adopted her son. As long as Irving can protect them, give them a good home and take care of them, that is what matters. There is no mention of love – let alone true love – or being a good role model for his son. In fact, Irving acknowledges early on that he does not love Rosalyn and it was a mutually agreed upon arrangement to help provide stability and a father figure for her son – a marriage of convenience. At the same time, this is how Irving justifies having a girlfriend.

The official trailer for “American Hustle.” 

Of course, Rosalyn’s personal character isn’t much better. She’s a stay-at-home mom who is too self-absorbed and concerned with having nice things to pay much attention to her young boy. Zoned out on painkillers or alcohol, her son is left to take care of himself. There are times in the movie when it almost seems as if Sydney would be a better mother. She comes off as an educated and bright woman with a desire to succeed in life, whereas Rosalyn is portrayed as lazy, vain and uncaring, an all too common comparison in films.

In order for Irving to succeed in the scam, he must prove to the mayor he’s a good family man and devoted husband. This means bringing Rosalyn along as they socialize with the mayor. The scam threatens to unravel though when Irving’s wife learns about Sydney and her husband’s growing love for his mistress. All three, Irving, Rosalyn and Sydney, are forced to re-evaluate what it means to be a family, a parent, a good wife and good husband. With the predictability of Hollywood, though, “love” wins out with Irving and Sydney raising Rosalyn’s son while Rosalyn goes off into the sunset, free of the burden of her son, with someone who loves her for who she is.

“August: Osage County” shows another typical Hollywood view of marriage and family – that of the dysfunctional family. Violet Weston (Meryl Streep), mother of three daughters, is the family’s chain-smoking matriarch with throat cancer who is also addicted to painkillers and is an alcoholic. We quickly discover she is a mean-spirited person who doesn’t seem to love anyone but herself. Even her husband ultimately decides one morning to end his life rather than spend another agonizing minute with her. Her oldest daughter, Barbara (Julia Roberts), appears to be equally as mean-spirited with an unhappy marriage as well. The second-oldest daughter, Ivy, is the one who took care of her mother for years when her sisters moved away and so endured her mother’s regular taunts and demeaning comments. She is also hiding a big secret – she and her first cousin are in love and want to marry. The youngest daughter appears to have been ignored by her mother altogether and has become a carefree woman who has gone from one failed relationship to another. She returns home with her newest fiancé, who subsequently tries to encourage Barbara’s teenage daughter to share marijuana with him. Rounding out the family scene is Violet’s sister, Mattie, who also harbors a deep secret: that the father of her son was Violet’s husband.

The official trailer for “August: Osage County.”

From beginning to end, with the family coming together for the funeral of Violet’s husband, it is one family argument after another, with Violet slinging insults at each of her daughters. No one is immune from her sharp and acrid tongue. At one point, however, Violet confides to her daughters that her own mother was equally cruel and this was how she learned to treat others. The daughters get to take their anger out on their mother as well. The climax for this dysfunctional family is Violet’s revelation that she knew her husband was going to end his life but chose not to do or say anything because she wanted to be free of him and wanted his money. In the end, she gets her wish as all of her family members walk out on her.

“Blue Jasmine,” while not as extreme as “August: Osage County,” presents another common view of marriage as an ephemeral relationship and family as an impossible ideal. Jasmine French (Cate Blanchett) is a lost soul seeking to reconnect with her sister and find meaning again since the suicide of her former husband and loss of all her money. Jasmine’s marriage to Hal (Alec Baldwin) was perfect – or so it seemed to her. She was married to a very successful businessman who gave her everything she ever wanted. She lived in a mansion in the exclusive Hamptons of Long Island and was surrounded by friends and life was perfect – or so it seemed.

The official trailer for “Blue Jasmine.”

Her life, however, begins to crumble around her. First, Jasmine learns her husband has been unfaithful with a string of women. On top of that, Hal is convicted and sentenced to prison for multiple accounts of fraud. But, unable to face a prison experience, he commits suicide. One by one, her friends abandon her. Even her stepson doesn’t want to be around her, finding her to be a shallow and vain woman. The icing on the cake is when the bank seizes all of Jasmine’s remaining assets to pay back the defrauded investors.

Homeless, penniless and alone, Jasmine turns to her step-sister, Ginger, and asks if she can come to San Francisco and stay with her and her two sons. From the moment she arrives, she realizes how different her life will be. Ginger lives in a small apartment, barely making enough to pay the bills. Though Jasmine snubbed her sister in the past and Hal had defrauded her and her husband out of their life savings resulting in their divorce, Ginger opens her home to Jasmine and tries to help her adjust and define a new life.

Faced with the opportunity to start fresh, Jasmine cannot seem to adapt. She becomes depressed as she tries to reclaim her fairy tale image of marriage and family, yet realizing it never really existed. She tries to rebuild her life and attempts to find a job to support herself and seeks to meet other men but without coming to grips with her flawed perspective of relationships, marriage and life. When she does finally seem to get back on her feet and meets someone who falls in love with her, she ends up spinning a series of lies to impress him so he will marry her and she will once again have a man who would take care of her so she can escape the real world once again. Of course, once the man discovers he has been lied to, he drives off leaving her alone at the side of the road like unwanted baggage.

These three films are consistent with Hollywood’s typical portrayal of marriage and family as based on premises such as: a) there is no such thing as true love; b) marriage is an impermanent relationship; c) if you aren’t happy in your marriage, find someone else; d) sexual relationships outside of marriage are acceptable if one is in love; and, e) most families are dysfunctional. When such movies receive a Golden Globe, Screen Actors Guild award or an Oscar, they reinforce these perspectives of marriage and family while making it difficult for those few films that do portray marriage as sacred and relationships built on genuine love to have an equal impact on the public perception.

In the end, though these three films gave us great casts and outstanding acting, I look for a time in which such perspectives are an aberration rather than the norm.♦ 

These three 2013 films received a total of 15 Oscar nominations this year; Cate Blanchett won the Oscar for “Best Actress.” They are now available on DVD and Blu-ray; via iTunes, the Google Play Store and Amazon Instant Video; as well as on-demand from major cable providers. “American Hustle” is distributed by Columbia Pictures and directed by David O. Russell; running time: 138 minutes. “August: Osage County” is distributed by the Weinstein Company and directed by John Wells; running time: 121 minutes. “Blue Jasmine” is distributed by Sony Pictures and directed by Woody Allen; running time: 98 minutes. 

Dr. Kathy Winings is Vice President for Academic Affairs, Director, Doctor of Ministry Program, and Professor of Religious Education and Ministry at UTS. She is also the Vice President of the Board of Directors for the International Relief Friendship Foundation.

Photo at top: A scene from “August: Osage County,” courtesy the Weinstein Company.

10 thoughts on “Let’s Hear It for the Dysfunctional Family

Add yours

  1. Hollywood put out three movies with incest scenes: “That’s My boy,” “The Samaritan” and “Old Boy.” There was “Movie 43” with a mom making out with her son scene. This, I think is part of a plan to purposely subvert the common sense of an entire generation of young people. Broken values lead to foolishness, foolishness to broken hearts, and people with broken hearts are more malleable.

  2. It’s understood that for a family to be truly functional, then the parents and children should all get along, love one another, and respect and trust each other. Further, sex should only occur within the bonds of marriage. Spouses simply would not cheat. There would be no reason in an environment of true love. In a normal, functioning family, the family’s assets should be shared freely with each other, without coveting or hoarding them. The family should relate to each other based on the quality of heart, rather than following prescribed laws. High standards, yes. But then again, it’s what everyone wants. After all, the Blessing is meant to be eternal.

    1. This is a great way to explain what a functional family should look like. It does not seem to be so complicated to make it into a reality, but yet it is.

      Why is it so challenging to be “functional”? If you ever read any of Eckhart Tolle’s books, A New Earth in particular, he talks about the pain body. All of us have a pain body that gets activated more intensely within the boundaries of the family. Strangely enough, we think that within the family love should flow so naturally but, in reality, that pain body’s activation stirs up feelings and emotions like anger, feeling unsupported, frustration, grief, etc., between husband and wife and with the children.

      It gets complicated as we are dealing with personal emotions and also inherited negative emotions. All of us have such baggage. Being in a family challenges us to minimize and ideally get rid of that baggage so we can give and receive love with no more sabotaging behaviors or negative self-destructive interferences. A family is a place of great potential for growth as we are challenged constantly to tame our own ego. As long as that ego is not tamed, there will be difficulties.

      As you wrote, Stephen, “it is what everyone wants.” This is true. Therefore, the more tools people have to overcome their ego and get rid of their pain body, and their fallen nature, the faster that goal of functional family can be reached.

      We need those tools. If we don’t have such tools, it is like we are continuously talking about an ideal house and all that is in front of us is a fixer-upper. No wonder there is so much frustration and disillusion. Since we come from a long line of fallen history, all of us are a “fixer-upper” or, as they say, “a work in progress.”

      May we find ways to help one another and encourage each other as families to make progress and find the peace, love, forgiveness, harmony and unconditional love we so long for.

  3. Such films are a reflection of the dysfunctional lives of the Hollywood set. This is their reality. In the past, Hollywood would pay at least lip-service to more traditional values, even as actors lives back then were already beginning to break away from them. We can only expect more of the same until people with a God-centered perspective enter the performing arts business and start producing works promoting marriage and family values, of which we can find some recent examples (e.g., T.D. Jakes).

  4. Hollywood does well to relate the odd character and life lesson (or lessons), whether hard or soft, for in the end, they are never wholly or solely factual (as so many disclaimers tell us). And in my estimation, as noted previously, on the opposite end of this spectrum (and more common) is the apocalyptic driven story with heroes and heroines, often beyond anything ever seen before, yet somehow also very relatable. We can wallow or soar — as ever the human spirit chooses. Nothing really has changed, despite the coming of true celluloid. All things still decay, but we can still choose to love and even love well!

  5. One could say, “Knowing the principle, to the depth that True Father does, allows us to untie the knots, to sort between Godly-purposed sex and fallen sex, to clear out the blur,” then we could say that “the Principle is sufficient and studying it is worthwhile.”

    If we think that even True Father was “unclear,” then we could say that “the Principle is insufficient, it’s not deep enough to grant us clarity. Studying it is ultimately not worthwhile.”

    Some who are perplexed by the behavior of providential figures have no choice but to go back to the default position, shrugging their shoulders, embracing the blur. But I believe there is a place, down deep, where it all makes sense and the Principle is able to lead people to that place. What Bob Beebe said couldn’t be truer than for people who have dug that deep and found gold. Truly Principled people should make all sorts of art including movies.

    The recent movie “God’s Not Dead” is just the tip of the Principle. We have more to offer.

  6. Platitudes based (mostly) upon popular culture memes (based upon folk tales and even “Holy” books) as well as the general prevalence of false views of history and the universe do nothing for anyone.

    Yes, dig deeper.

    That being said, however, it may really all be less important, in my humble opinion, than what “we” actually do — vis a vis “The Principle”: actual results – every day.

    God [within] help us save the True God.

  7. Kirk Cameron’s movie “Fireproof” was a great movie on family values. It was also a financial success: made on a budget of $500K, it made $33 million in the U.S. alone. So there is an audience out there for good movies. What is needed is more principled/faith-based people to make movies.

    R. Buckminster Fuller once said:

    “You never change things by fighting the existing reality. To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.”

    The world is waiting for that new model. Making a good movie is a better way to reach and teach the masses than campaigns, expensive conferences… People may not go to a church service, but they will go to the movies. It is a medium that has been underutilized for the purpose of helping people improve their spiritual lives.

    I must say that as trashy as Hollywood can be, the latest Disney production of “Maleficent” is quite refreshing as it deals with how evil can be restored into good in the heart of one person. It may only be one person, but it is a start. The scene of this movie that touched me the most is when Elle Fanning’s character looked in the eyes of Maleficent and said, innocently and with a pure heart: “You are my godmother.” She saw her from God’s point of view. She saw the good in her. This is what saved her and helped her turn around. A good lesson for all of us.

    1. I’ve seen a number of Christian movies on Netflix that never made the big screen because of superficial references to theology. It seems that when faith-based people want to make movies they end up shooting themselves in the foot because they imagine other people will see the world as they do if they say the right religious arguments. One mainstream TV show ,”Bluebloods,” is about a Catholic family that is fairly functional, which is why I think some people enjoy it.

      1. I agree with you, Gordon, that it is a fine balance to “get the message across” without falling into “church lingo/teaching/preaching” that seems to be cliche to those not of that faith. Instead of trying to preach using words or concepts that are not familiar with the greater crowd, movies that show authenticity, sincerity, the reality of the human condition and introduce a solution that comes from the heart — not from a theology which can be seen as a brand name — this will touch the wider base.

        In the UM, we have fallen also into the pit of using certain terms that seems unfamiliar, borderline foreign, and really foreign when speaking of CIG….There goes the challenge: how to convey the message using everyday words and everyday situations. Keeping it simple. Keeping it real. Now that is a winner.

Use the box below to submit a new comment (To reply, click "Reply" within a specific comment above)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

A WordPress.com Website.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: